Friends,
Lets post updates on our apps which are waiting for review, ie In Review. And also post an update when they are online.
This thread will give us an expected review date.
I start with:
submit date: 8th Sept
approved 5 days back
submit date: 12th Sept.
Still in review.
Post edited by observer247 on
100 apps at the app store. 2 million app downloads. Helped launch 3 funded startups ! Outsource your iPhone development to an experienced development team.
My first app was approved fairly quickly (submitted 9/5, on sale 9/11) but this latest app, which I'm 10x more excited about, has been waiting for Apple to bless it's existence since 9/8/08!
It's making me crazy because I'd scheduled a day for video production, and I've had to cancel. I was intending to actually do some marketing of this one, because it's the kind of thing nobody realizes they want until you show them. My third app has been put on hold until there's more clarity about the marketplace. And besides, maybe I'm an emotional whimp, but I just can't focus on the next project when the last one is in limbo.
Category: travel
type: first submission x 2
applications: One lets you find open radio stations in your area: iTunes link
The other uses the same database of radio stations to find open spectrum for things like iTrip: iTunes link
submit date: sept 5 x 2
approved date: sept 12 x 2
category: entertainment
type: first submit
application: spectrograph
submit date: sept 23
approved date: still waiting
Category: medical coding (Lite)
type: first submit
submit date: sept 9
review date: sept 18
rejected: large icon different from small icon - resubmitted next day
status: still waiting
category: medical coding (Commercial)
type: first submit
submit date: sept 12
rejected: large icon different from small icon - resubmitted next day
review date: sept 18
status: still waiting
I have some updates and am wondering if I can reject the binaries and resubmit without going back to the end of the queue. Some definitive experience regarding this would be helpful. For example, if someone rejected their binary and resubmitted, then got approved the next day then that would be good evidence that resubmitting your binary does not put it at the end of the queue.
Update - Both apps now "Ready for Sale" Fri. Sep 26 10:44pm - Somebody's working late over at Apple. You're my hero, iTunes Store [Do_not_reply@apple.com]. Let me buy you a drink next time I'm in Cupertino/Bangladesh. Behind that off-putting email address I'll bet you're a pretty cool guy.
I've been waiting for ALMOST ONE MONTH, which is very annoying.
Submit: Sep 5th,
Oct 2nd : Still Review.
They just emailed me a week ago, and said "We require additional time. Sorry for the delay...". Since my app is soooo simple that it took just a week last time I submitted another one, I don't understand why they take such a long time and don't explain much. Apple disrespect developers in a sense...
I've been waiting for ALMOST ONE MONTH, which is very annoying.
Submit: Sep 5th,
Oct 2nd : Still Review.
They just emailed me a week ago, and said "We require additional time. Sorry for the delay...". Since my app is soooo simple that it took just a week last time I submitted another one, I don't understand why they take such a long time and don't explain much. Apple disrespect developers in a sense...
Hey what kind of app is it? Does it compete with the native apps? Also what do you mean by you submitted another one? You submitted twice for the same app?
My app is pretty simple so that it uses WebView and some other functions of native Obj-C.
>Also what do you mean by you submitted another one?
I actually submitted the one in the previous version, which is not submitting the same one twice. After getting Apple's feedback, I modified/added some further functions and submitted it again. Last time I submitted, it took only a week to hear from Apple, while this time it's been ONE MONTH.
My app is pretty simple so that it uses WebView and some other functions of native Obj-C.
>Also what do you mean by you submitted another one?
I actually submitted the one in the previous version, which is not submitting the same one twice. After getting Apple's feedback, I modified/added some further functions and submitted it again. Last time I submitted, it took only a week to hear from Apple, while this time it's been ONE MONTH.
Hey same here, the first version I submitted took 1 week and got rejected. The resubmit is now taking 1 MONTH. Maybe we get punished for resubmits
Does anyone have any feedback as to whether it is a quicker review process for a company rather than an individual, or vice versa?
Also is it quicker for subsequent apps once your first app has been approved?
Cheers
Dave
From other conversations, I don't believe it's any quicker as a company. Even EA and Atari have to go through testing and compliance, but you can expect their own internal QA will make it a smoother ride as the submissions will be better documented (particularly path to completion and finding features, when applicable/important) and will be tested more thoroughly than the average 'indie' submission. Having a voice contact will also help of course: Never underestimate the power of verbal communication - everyone in business should know not to rely on email.
As for re-submissions (regarding rejections), it sort of makes sense that they will take longer. It's nothing personal, but the volume of submissions probably means there are two qeues: First Chance and Second Chance. New subs, to be fair, should be processed quickly as possible. Apps that have been rejected, and re-submitted, by proxy will be treated as "could still have problems" ... otherwise the turnover would be impaired by apps that never get their problems fixed (however many that may be - it could be a few, it could be hundreds!).
Following up to my early post in this thread (this time with more details as wisely suggested)...
Category: Entertainment / Lifestyle
type: First submission
submit date: September 8
approved date: STILL IN REVIEW
I called ADC support and got a case number, we all know how useless that tends to be, but it makes me feel better than doing nothing. This particular app is pretty unconventional and, while I'm very proud of it, has a couple aspects that might give the reviewers pause. Still, a month is plenty of time! At the end of the day, it's an original idea that adds a fun new way to use your iPhone to the app store... they really should approve it.
hobbyCoder: does your app in any way compete with the native apps? Mine kinda does so I guess that's why mine took 1 month also. ....
No, there's nothing else quite like my app anywhere to my knowledge. By its very nature it requires a peculiar user interface, which I assume is the issue. But a month is stupidly long to expect a developer to wait for the review process. Especially when XPlane, uploaded the same day as my app was approved from initial submission to release in only three days. (My app is also 10x less complicated, of course).
observer247
Posts: 112Registered Users @ @
Replies
It's making me crazy because I'd scheduled a day for video production, and I've had to cancel. I was intending to actually do some marketing of this one, because it's the kind of thing nobody realizes they want until you show them. My third app has been put on hold until there's more clarity about the marketplace. And besides, maybe I'm an emotional whimp, but I just can't focus on the next project when the last one is in limbo.
This is getting ridiculous!!
DigiDrummer
took exactly a week
from review to release on Appstore. Pretty okey.
My current app was sent to Apple on Sept 22. Still waiting...
Category: productivity
type: update
submit date: sept 15
approved date: sept 22
category: business
type: first submit
submit date: sept 11
approved date: still waiting
type: first submission x 2
applications: One lets you find open radio stations in your area: iTunes link
The other uses the same database of radio stations to find open spectrum for things like iTrip: iTunes link
submit date: sept 5 x 2
approved date: sept 12 x 2
category: entertainment
type: first submit
application: spectrograph
submit date: sept 23
approved date: still waiting
-C
Notice Software
type: first submit
submit date: sept 9
review date: sept 18
rejected: large icon different from small icon - resubmitted next day
status: still waiting
category: medical coding (Commercial)
type: first submit
submit date: sept 12
rejected: large icon different from small icon - resubmitted next day
review date: sept 18
status: still waiting
I have some updates and am wondering if I can reject the binaries and resubmit without going back to the end of the queue. Some definitive experience regarding this would be helpful. For example, if someone rejected their binary and resubmitted, then got approved the next day then that would be good evidence that resubmitting your binary does not put it at the end of the queue.
Update - Both apps now "Ready for Sale" Fri. Sep 26 10:44pm - Somebody's working late over at Apple. You're my hero, iTunes Store [Do_not_reply@apple.com]. Let me buy you a drink next time I'm in Cupertino/Bangladesh. Behind that off-putting email address I'll bet you're a pretty cool guy.
Let the bad reviews commence!
type: first submit
submit date: sept 7
approved date: sept 12
category: music
type: update
submit date: sept 21
approved date: still in review
<a href="http://phobos.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewSoftware?id=290593307&mt=8"; target="_blank">XyPhone</a> (App Store link)
my first app was preview within a week (realy simple app, just data display)...
but my contrzct has been in the woks for a long time...cant wait for it to finalize...
iphone and trains in Denmark</a>
Then wouldn't the submission date reset to the date you re-uploaded your binary?
<a href="http://www.tapforms.com"; target="_blank">http://www.tapforms.com</a><br />
<a href="http://twitter.com/brendand"; target="_blank">http://twitter.com/brendand</a>;
Submit: Sep 5th,
Oct 2nd : Still Review.
They just emailed me a week ago, and said "We require additional time. Sorry for the delay...". Since my app is soooo simple that it took just a week last time I submitted another one, I don't understand why they take such a long time and don't explain much. Apple disrespect developers in a sense...
Hey what kind of app is it? Does it compete with the native apps? Also what do you mean by you submitted another one? You submitted twice for the same app?
>Also what do you mean by you submitted another one?
I actually submitted the one in the previous version, which is not submitting the same one twice. After getting Apple's feedback, I modified/added some further functions and submitted it again. Last time I submitted, it took only a week to hear from Apple, while this time it's been ONE MONTH.
Hey same here, the first version I submitted took 1 week and got rejected. The resubmit is now taking 1 MONTH. Maybe we get punished for resubmits
Also is it quicker for subsequent apps once your first app has been approved?
Cheers
Dave
From other conversations, I don't believe it's any quicker as a company. Even EA and Atari have to go through testing and compliance, but you can expect their own internal QA will make it a smoother ride as the submissions will be better documented (particularly path to completion and finding features, when applicable/important) and will be tested more thoroughly than the average 'indie' submission. Having a voice contact will also help of course: Never underestimate the power of verbal communication - everyone in business should know not to rely on email.
As for re-submissions (regarding rejections), it sort of makes sense that they will take longer. It's nothing personal, but the volume of submissions probably means there are two qeues: First Chance and Second Chance. New subs, to be fair, should be processed quickly as possible. Apps that have been rejected, and re-submitted, by proxy will be treated as "could still have problems" ... otherwise the turnover would be impaired by apps that never get their problems fixed (however many that may be - it could be a few, it could be hundreds!).
Category: Entertainment / Lifestyle
type: First submission
submit date: September 8
approved date: STILL IN REVIEW
I called ADC support and got a case number, we all know how useless that tends to be, but it makes me feel better than doing nothing. This particular app is pretty unconventional and, while I'm very proud of it, has a couple aspects that might give the reviewers pause. Still, a month is plenty of time! At the end of the day, it's an original idea that adds a fun new way to use your iPhone to the app store... they really should approve it.
No, there's nothing else quite like my app anywhere to my knowledge. By its very nature it requires a peculiar user interface, which I assume is the issue. But a month is stupidly long to expect a developer to wait for the review process. Especially when XPlane, uploaded the same day as my app was approved from initial submission to release in only three days. (My app is also 10x less complicated, of course).
ADC / iTunes Connect dabase has a serious bug about multi-byte character issue.
If you have any non alphabet character in your account, ask them.
In my case they never help me....
Is there a way to contact them by phone? I called 1-800-my-apple but they do not have the slightest clue and said i need to look on the website.
They cant cope with the ammount of developers and it costs them too much or what?:rolleyes:
<br />
Main Website: <a href="http://www.TheRedThing.com"; target="_blank">The Red Thing</a> and <a href="http://www.youtube.com/use
Do you have the ADC telephone number by chance?
<br />
Main Website: <a href="http://www.TheRedThing.com"; target="_blank">The Red Thing</a> and <a href="http://www.youtube.com/use